
UPDATED
This is an old History Is A Weapon poster (the original had a bunch of arrows turning on themselves). It’s cool to see your words reappear elsewhere, their resonance still going strong.
UPDATED
So we wrote this a long time ago and then reposted it this morning when we saw that it was making the rounds on TUMBLR, albeit with a radically different design. But in our morning stupor, we missed all the comments in it, so we wanted to respond.
This isn’t an argument for “brocialism” (wtf?), excusing bad behavior, silencing dissent, or solidarity in place of intersectionalism. Really. We’re pretty big proponents of intersectionality and taking flaming pitchforks to transphobic misogynist racist capitalist swine. We’re not just saying that. Look through History Is A Weapon and see what we’re trying to put out there. If you knew us in the real world, you’d know we mean this.
This poster was made for two reasons.
First, we’re sick and tired of drunken arguments about the Spanish civil war. We’re bored with the posturing. We don’t have time for the games of play pretend activism where everyone dons the uniform of 68 or Mao or whatevs and pretends. We’re here to win, and if you think there isn’t winning, you’ve never really been hungry or needed something before, like medical care, for someone you loved that you couldn’t have because you didn’t have enough money.
Second, and here’s the part where we lose a bunch of you who are will start hating History Is A Weapon, but we have to say it because it’s what we believe.
There are two poles in American Left Activism: the subculturalists and the mass movement.
The subculturalists are great, we love you, we drink with you, but we’re not you. You show up, you identify, a bunch of you seem lefter than thou, do all the most radical acts, get arrested, spraypaint, coordinate actions, raise hell, wonderful. But you think this is your club and you could’ve picked star trek or singing with the stars or radiohead or the grateful dead or fixing up cars or knitting or whatever. You picked lefty politics as your little club, and like the indie rock kids whining that they heard of the band before everyone else, you want your politics pure and clean and just right. You tend your book collection and you weed out your friends and you know the right answer to every question the 101s ask you.
We don’t hate you, we love you, but we’re part of the second group.
We’re here to make radical change, not in a safe space, but everywhere. And we work with everyone who’ll have us and listen and participate and teach us and help us grow. We’re not trying to coordinate our friends on a road trip to the action, we’re trying to spark something with people we’ve never met, organize the uninitiated, with all of their hang ups, with all of our hang ups, knowing that the homophobic jerk who gets it on wall street and the war but still says the F word because he doesn’t know any better yet, is a product of the same sexist homophobic racist transphobic capitalist society that we are, and here’s the kicker, we’re not going to discover some fifty first state with a hundred million people who are down with the cause. These are the people who we make the revolution with and we can’t do it if we spiral into a crystalized community of the eight other perfect vegans, we have to spiral out into a mass movement that loves people and grows with them, moving them along and helping them, not excusing it if they say sexist nonsense or try to shut people of color down or make trans jokes or whatevs, but that nurtures and grows with them.
Because, and here is where we’re just really upset but it needs to be said, CeCe McDonald is not in a “safe space.” She’s in a scary jail. And if we mean what we say and we want to make a world where CeCe gets to live her life and be who she wants to be, then we need to create a movement fierce and large enough to become a threat, to be a force to be reckoned with, something so powerful that by its very form, it cannot be repressed or co-opted because it becomes like the hurricane wind or the tidal wave, an unstoppable force tearing down the structures of ignorance and hate and their systems of reproduction. And if we mean that, and we’re going to do it, we have to have less purges and more community, more work and less infighting, less nonsense and more revolution.
And none of this, not a word, is an argument against holding sexist behavior accountable or silencing people of any identity in the name of solidarity, but rather in saying we need to deal with it in a way that grows our power from within in a way that fortifies our struggle.
(Seriously, we’re sick of the Spanish war arguments. The conflict was pretty specific, we’re not working within that context, and get over yourselves. And if you find yourself in a room/party where it’s being debated, just take a breather until people chill.)
(Source: amodernmanifesto)