Attack Ships on Fire wrote:et in Arcadia ego wrote:I don't recall an outright admittance in the novella that Project Arrowhead was indeed responsible. Doesn't mean its not there, just that I don't recall it, and I've read it many times. I have both Dark Forces as well as Skeleton Crew(somewhere...)
The Arrowhead Project was implied that it was the cause of the mist. In the story the people in the grocery store found the soldiers in the back store room hanging by their necks. In the movie there are 3 army soldiers. 1 is given a bigger role and he directly admits that the Arrowhead Project was trying to open holes into other dimensions. There is also a cocooned MP in the pharmacy that tells the grocery people the military was responsible for what happened just before he dies.
Right, but in the story they never make that more than a working assumption. I'd have preferred it to stay that way; the uncertainty was an attractive quality.
Attack Ships on Fire wrote:But if Darabont put the same actors amongst the survivors in the military convoy that the hero sees passing him by, that is a huge issue. What is that supposed to have meant? That he should have stayed inside the grocery store when they were getting ready to lynch him and his son? That evil people get rewarded? That if you do nothing and go with the group think you live happily ever after?
I don't think so. Luck has no bias. I refer again to the Director's maneuver towards a Greek style tragedy, which always has the strongest impact when irony is present. It leads you to think damned if you do, damned if you don't, a common enough thought that passes through many of our heads in day to day life. I don't get the impression that Darabont believes in rewarding evil behavior. In his interview he mirrors many of our own general observations here at RI:
The 21st Century is fux0red.
Attack Ships on Fire wrote:It's like he wanted the bleakest ending for the hero and movie possible. Even in the story the hero doesn't find out the fate of his wife, in the movie he sees her dead.
et in Arcadia ego wrote:Are we sure about this? his is another gray spot for me. I could have sworn he goes into the house after they leave the grocery..
I'm sure that he doesn't. In the novella the hero can't get to his house because the road is torn up after the earthquake that happened once he was in town. He can't get closure that his wife is living or dead and he has to turn around and head out of town. It's very ambiguous. In the movie it's clearly seen that she was killed by the mist spiders.
Cheers, its been a minute since I read it, couldn't be sure.
Attack Ships on Fire wrote:The ending changes are just so odd, especially considering how very faithful Darabont was to the original up until that point.
et in Arcadia ego wrote:Supposedly this guy is pretty tight with King, so basing logic on this, I'm not sure he's doing something against King's wishes, fwiw.
Add to that the hero's senseless logic in driving until he runs out of gas and I'm left wondering why Darabont chose this ending.
The hero's lapse in good thinking is clearly the stitch in the script where Darabont departs from the original storyline. This is probably just a crowbar effect neccessary to superimpose his own ending.
Attack Ships on Fire wrote:As a matter of fact I can't recall any times that King has called out bad adaptations of his material unless the quality is really dreadful (for example, any of the "Children of the Corn" shows.)
Well, let's be honest. King's been a whore for quite some time now. Personally, I walked away form his writing right at or soon after 'It'(what a horridly written mass of shite that was..). In the interview I gave a link to he doesn't miss a beat and recommends his new book released in January as a great gift, etc, blah blah.
King likes the dough, bro.
So, all this aside, we have at least a year to speculate on how The Thing is going to be mutilated. Whatchu think about that one? Apparently there's production details that can be found on IMDB, but a pro membership is required. I thought about doing a trial of the pro service just to rip the data..
Call your film buddies and ask em about it! I got a guy in Lion's Gate but he doesn't know anything about it..
edit: disaster formatting repair