This is my last post on this thread for the next 11 days.
Nordic wrote:so, jack, why do you think gold and silver has been used as money for thousands of years and by various cultures of the world? was it just coincidence? accident?
Because of shared belief that it was money. Obviously. Especially strong among the ones who were in possession of the metal. Obviously. Not universal to all times, cultures, or situations. Because of social consensus often enforced by sword. As one of many other forms of exchange employed. All obviously.
Mostly in agrarian slave civilizations. Sorry. 90 percent of everyone worked a plot of land, traveled no further than a few miles in their lives, and consumed mainly stuff produced on the same plot of land. For those unlucky enough to be within the reach of an empire, tributes in wheat bundles kept the organized bandits of the nobility at bay, most years. Not all of them ever got to see one of the coins used as specie for transactions in the towns and castles.
Spartans sneered at gold because they were the first ones in their neighborhood to really get the hang of iron, which made them powerful. Worked for hundreds of years. Later they got overwhelmed by richer places that could buy power with gold. Those civilizations are now nice ruins to visit. Which was more real, gold or iron? Neither. Both. Depends.
I've added some color-coded commentary to your next passage:
the way you think the world should be is irrelavent to how it actually is. and for thousands of years gold and silver have been "real" money. money that can cross borders, won't rot in storage[also true of US dollars], is impossible to counterfeit[wrong] or simply manufacture,[why is this good? because you prefer mine-owners to bankers?] and can be readily melted down and cast into new shapes and sizes.[modern number-currencies are also very flexible] its certainly not just another commodity.
All of these reasons boil down to one: faith. Fiat or fetish? All money is money because you think it is (because these magic shiny qualities seem to make it so for you) and, more importantly, others are willing to accept it as exchange.
What's really fascinating here is that your "thousands of years" do not currently apply. Right this moment, gold is not money in almost any actual case. Gold trades are done by bookkeeping exchanges denominated in fiat currency. The gold stays in the same place after a trade, and may not be available to its current owner after the hyperinflation arrives (which will make you so very very right at last!).
So the PM-bugs go for the physical stuff. But physical PMs are not used as specie. Right now, they are not real money. Right now, real money are the fiat currencies. Right now, fiat is real and fetish is thousands of years of dead history.
In other words, you're storing something that isn't money today in the assumption that some set of unknowable contingencies will activate the conditions under which it turns into money tomorrow. As a medium of exchange, it's more real than the paper stuff only in your assumed future, not now.
It makes more sense if you're planning on selling the PM commodity once it reaches what you believe is its peak price in real money. Which is what a lot of people who have gone into the PMs hope to do, creating much of the demand that has raised prices.
An interesting feature of modernity is that its advent was still denied after several centuries in which no one lived as they had before and evidence of it was in everything from the dna to the shape of the earth. Your fetish of gold is based on the idea that it will be money after some future event, but you too know that it is not money right now. The thing that makes it money is yet to come.
In many of the wide range of possible post-collapse scenarios of our modern day varieties of apocalyptism, depending on how it plays out, joining a prayer group or the right cult and conditioning yourself to their mores and lingo and being part of whatever mutual exchange they set up may be more effective as a survival mechanism than storing physical gold. Because there is no way to tell what happens. Of course, because there is no way to tell what happens, people insist on having a certain answer to which they can cling and banish the horrible uncertainty. Fetish. Totem. Some accumulate gold as this thing that will help them after this thing that will happen. Others accumulate prayer-hours.
All wealth originates in nature. Labor and applied energy create use-value. Exchange value is adjusted by belief and struggle. In the long run, we are all dead.
.