Elvis » Sat Sep 07, 2013 2:57 pm wrote:American Dream » Thu Sep 05, 2013 6:39 pm wrote:Elvis » Thu Sep 05, 2013 8:28 pm wrote:American Dream » Thu Sep 05, 2013 11:35 am wrote: http://www.social-ecology.org/1996/01/l ... ctives-35/
From Green Messiah to New Age Nazi
by Matthew Kalman and John Murray
Matthew Kalman and John Murray are editors of the eco-political investigative magazine Open Eye, which has been uncovering and exposing David Icke and “New Age Nazism.” Address: BM Open Eye, London WC1N 3XX. Issue 3 is available for £1.70.
It has been hard in recent years to ignore the rising popularity of almost everything that comes under the heading New Age. Yoga, meditation, Kabbalah, Buddhism, alternative medicine, environmentalism, and self-improvement, as well as an array of New Age therapies, have all gained in popularity, as have other fringe interests like UFOs and the paranormal, which often appeal to the same people. Few will have avoided at least some contact.
The movement even has its own stars. In Britain, David Icke, the TV sports commentator turned Green Party national spokesman turned purple-robed “Son of God,” is the best-known leader.
What this is saying is that yoga, meditation, Kabbalah, Buddhism, alternative medicine, environmentalism, self-improvement, UFOs and the paranormal are all part of a monolithic "movement" led by David Icke, and anyone who has not "avoided at least some contact" with these pernicious ideas is, if not already an anti-semitic Holocaust revisionist who reads the Spotlight, is in grave danger of being "enticed" onto the "anti-Semitic treadmill."
That's an enormous stretch, AD, do you really take such a claim seriously?
David Icke should be given a hard look, no question about that. His website forums are populated with real, actual nazis and Hitler-lovers. But -- practicing yoga leads to David Icke and the slippery antisemitic slope? Environmentalism?
This is starting to be outright offensive.
Do I think that "practicing yoga leads to David Icke and the slippery antisemitic slope? Environmentalism?"
Hardly! I practice both and I'm clearly not into David Icke. I do think he has drawn sustenance from the New Age and broadly links himself to those sorts of currents.
What though do you think though of the evidence that Icke veers into racism and the far right? That is what is should be disturbing to a thinking, moral and socially aware person, in my book....
What I'm saying is, I can't understand why you'd bolster your point with a weak thesis condemning yoga and environmentalism (etc.) as evil facets of a racist "movement" led by David Icke. The authors are either incredibly sloppy thinkers and researchers, or plain dishonest. Their real targets seem to be everything 'alternative', linking them all -- yoga, environmentalism etc. -- with David Icke and the racist right; I'm surprised that doesn't offend you.
To answer your question, I think Icke veers all over the road and there's no question that he picks up far-right kooks and "Hitler-not-such-a-bad-guy" nutcases. My advice to friends is to stay away from that bathwater. Landing in his forum on some unrelated Google search, I was just astonished that those poisonous posters are allowed to continue there (I don't know what the moderation policies are, if any, but that short visit gave me added appreciation of the moderating principles here on this forum).
So I'm with you on the need to discern racism when it comes in pretty packages, but let's also discern the value of our sources when exposing it. I think you've made your case sufficiently without resorting to articles like the one above and the pathetically inconsequential "Consprituality" piece.
Hey Elvis-
I'm glad we agree on the racist elements in Icke's work. As to Matthew Kalman and John Murray, you have a much harsher reading of them than I do. I see them as anti-Fascist types criticizing the infiltration of the far Right and its ideas into New Age circles. The statement I would most take issue with is "David Icke.. is the best-known leader. " This really is unfair to the New Age milieu- which is not a centralized movement anyway. Icke is the leader of the David Icke movement, which does draw succor from New Age circles- but that really is different than what this grossly distorted sentence from Kalman and Murray sentence suggests.
That said, I'm not imagining them as sweepingly anti-New Age but rather as people who must be hip to that culture no matter how much they are personally into everything about the latest guru or trance channel. Perhaps I'm wrong- but that was my reading...