Moderators: Elvis, DrVolin, Jeff
Perelandra » Wed Aug 06, 2014 12:24 pm wrote:I think so. A couple posters may want their dumps in GD, but that doesn't mean it should be allowed. All your common-sense ideas are why you have my vote for a new moderator.stefano » Wed Aug 06, 2014 6:27 am wrote:General Discussion is a good thing, and as shown by pageviews at least, is still the only forum that most visitors by far look at. You 'view active topics' peeps are early adopters, at the innovative frontier of board browsing behaviour. GD can be kept general by moderation - limiting the proliferation of threads so that many different topics are on the first page. At the moment, for instance, two Palestine threads are plenty: Zionism's lost shine is about... well, that, attitudes to Israel and the occupation, while Gaza ground invasion is about the current assault. There's no need for Do Palestinians have a right to self-defense, or Israel's war crimes, and We need a new Israel thread!!!!! is just taking the piss. Mods could post in there saying "This is getting moved to the Middle East subforum in an hour, feel free to post the OP in a different thread if you want your post in GD."
Good point also about GD threads that contain no discussion. They're Data Dump threads. Perhaps mods could post in them and ask if anyone would object to their being moved.
That'll help already. I'm not big on bannings, this place already feels less diverse than it used to be, and I think active moving and locking of threads will limit disruptive behaviour. At least on GD. Although I'm not sure if mods have the permissions to move threads. Do they?
So many others have good ideas, also. IMO, we need subfora. This place is like a library or large bookseller which requires order to be useful to all. GD is the current events corner, as well as the not-so-current for which new details can be shared.What would be superior to PMs, DIY chatrooms, or RL networking, if that's your interest? Keep it simple.Luther Blissett » Wed Aug 06, 2014 5:38 am wrote:Or at least a portal to a more secure location where fellow members can plan and organize behind projects. I appreciate the technical and incentive hurdles to get there but I think it's one of the next logical steps for this community.
JMO and thanks to those who make it work and keep it fun. OEGWO, lol.
Neither of them is interested in discussion. This is what AD has to say about his epic:Wombaticus Rex » Thu Aug 07, 2014 5:16 am wrote:Overall, I think this issue will just continue to shake out along the lines of personal preference. The Data Dump is the biggest reason I'm still here, I think it is fantastic. On a personal/aesthetic level, I think AD and Fruh's threads don't belong in General Discussion, but clearly they do. I'm willing to abide it.
Talk about masturbating into a broken mirror, sounds like a data dump to me. Or the blog function could be useful, so the fans could easily subscribe, or whatever.a great deal of very important material- revealing things that are essentially unknown and of great significance
No drama is necessary. It just needs a little routine maintenance. Jeff could appear for a short time, appoint a couple new mods, delegate a little, then go back to real life. Things could hum along much more smoothly, probably for quite some time, I'd think.Saurian Tail makes superb points. This infrastructure is creaky. Then again, "efficiency ≠ resiliency." Hopefully the same crap that makes this clunky is also keeping us online, eh? I am reduced to invoking hope because, let's face it, there is no "good management" mothership coming to save RI.
Perelandra » Thu Aug 07, 2014 12:57 pm wrote: Jeff could appear for a short time, appoint a couple new mods, delegate a little, then go back to real life. Things could hum along much more smoothly, probably for quite some time, I'd think.
Once we get an actual Admin amongst the mods
Wombaticus Rex » Thu Aug 07, 2014 1:00 pm wrote:Perelandra » Thu Aug 07, 2014 12:57 pm wrote: Jeff could appear for a short time, appoint a couple new mods, delegate a little, then go back to real life. Things could hum along much more smoothly, probably for quite some time, I'd think.
Pleased to report that is going to unfold shortly. Once we get an actual Admin amongst the mods, we'll be able to implement subforum requests, too.
Project Willow » Sun Sep 21, 2014 9:11 am wrote:^ Yes, discussions are in progress, but we may continue as we are for awhile yet. Thank you all for your patience.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 75 guests