Moderators: Elvis, DrVolin, Jeff
crikkett wrote:@Meho_M: Friend in #Egypt reports: "My friend just received orders from his state-owned company to go join the pro-Mubarak protests" #Jan25
@esraa_ali: Confirmed news...100 EGP is the price for the person who will go with #Mubarak fake demo#jan25 #Egypt
Alternative History: America's Iraq Atrocity and the Arab Awakening
WRITTEN BY CHRIS FLOYD
WEDNESDAY, 02 FEBRUARY 2011 14:14
One argument forever touted by apologists for the invasion of Iraq is that the war was worth it – despite all the “mistakes” that arose from our excess of good intentions – if only because it removed Saddam Hussein from power. This is the chief line taken by Tony Blair, one of the principals in the on-going war crime, which has spawned a million needless deaths already and is producing more with every passing week.
Blair – who now cheerfully admits that the WMD casus belli was bullshit from the beginning, and that the blatantly illegal goal of “regime change” was the goal all along – continually paints a nightmare scenario of a ruthless dictator still wielding an iron rod over his suffering people. “Can you imagine what would be happening if Saddam were in power today?!”
Well, as it turns out, we can imagine what would be happening: We would very likely be seeing Saddam Hussein announcing his intention to stand down at the next election, and promising that his sons would not take over in his place, while instituting reforms to widen political participation in the government. Heck, we might even be seeing him hastily boarding an airplane to Saudi Arabia, with a mob at his heels. We would, in other words, be seeing him in panic mode at the Arab uprising now sweeping across the Middle East.
This wave of broad-based popular revolution has -- in less than a month! -- already toppled one seemingly-entrenched dictator in Tunisia; forced an even more seemingly-entrenched dictator in Egypt to announce his impending retirement upon elections (and may yet still send him packing posthaste); impelled another entrenched strongman in Yemen to do the same; and forced still another entrenched autocrat to sack his government in Jordan and institute new reforms. In each case, these actions have been compelled by the anger – and great courage – of hundreds of thousands of ordinary people coming out on the streets, facing down tanks, troops and torturers to demand a new and more just order in their societies. It is one of the most remarkable movements in modern history. And it would have doubtless swept into a Saddam-controlled Iraq as well.
Without the murderous invasion of Iraq by the Anglo-American power structure, more than a million innocent people – including hundreds of thousands of children – would be alive today. The violent and virulent religious extremists unleashed -- and often armed and empowered by the occupiers -- would not be there. The Iranian influence in Iraq– so feared and decried by Washington – would be nil. The once-strong Christian population of Iraq would still be there, not fleeing for its life from the hatreds loosed by the war crime launched by two leaders who endlessly paraded their fervent Christianity. And we could now be seeing ordinary Iraqis – secular and sectarian, Sunni and Shiite, young and old – coming together, as in Egypt, to take charge of their own destiny.
Of course, Iraq may yet be touched by the Arab Awakening – although now this would have to take place in a ruined, shattered, fractious, ravaged land ... and with a vast, bristling American military machine still holding ultimate control. In a bitter irony, these “liberators” might be the one thing that stops the wave of genuine liberation from reaching Iraq.
NOTE: Simon Jenkins makes a similar point – and many other trenchant observations – in an excellent piece in the Guardian. Here’s an excerpt:
Had the west not intervened in Iraq and Afghanistan, I bet the Iraqi people would by now have found a way to be rid of Saddam. They or the army would have done what the Tunisians and the Egyptians are doing, and at far less cost in lives, upheaval and chaos. As for the Taliban, as clients of Islamabad they would have come to Pakistani heel. The Afghans would be a threat to nobody but themselves.
What history will call the Wars of 9/11 have killed immeasurably more people than did 9/11 itself. They have cost western taxpayers billions that would have gone far to relieving global disease and famine. American and British governments, for reasons embedded in some imperial paranoia, grotesquely exaggerated the threat posed to them by the Muslim world. They embarked on a campaign of intervention, regime change and nation building far from their shores. The campaign has been inept and counterproductive, as well as in breach of the United Nations charter on self-determination.
Egypt, Tunisia, Iran and Pakistan are all Muslim states wrestling with agonies of self-determination. The west's sole contribution has been to plunge two of their neighbours, Iraq and Afghanistan, into a bloodbath of insecurity and chaos. This is not our continent, these are not our countries and none of this is our business. We should leave them alone.
Jeff wrote:And Ground Hog Day is now leading the news.
twitter user @BloggerSeif wrote: 1. Its dark, fire on our way to army in Mogama. DO NOT USE ABDEEN PEOPLE! 4 minutes ago via Twitter for BlackBerry®
2.Heading back towards mogama, will say we are lost tourists, and the child is my brother. Rushdi will back us up. 6 minutes ago via Twitter for BlackBerry®
3.Omfg @TrellaLB if not abdine where :'( 7 minutes ago via Twitter for BlackBerry®
4.Alleyway in Abdeen is open for now, dunno for how long. Its geing dark, alleyway is open, getting out through there. 9 minutes ago via Twitter for BlackBerry®
5.Interviews? We want to live, we have to get out. Carrying child and @SarahKaram1 is rynning behind me. Rushdi bleeding, abdeen is open! 11 minutes ago via Twitter for BlackBerry®
6.My internatoional phones reception is too low to upload pics of him. 13 minutes ago via Twitter for BlackBerry®
7.Subways, use subways? I don't trust them, using omar makram! At least open... Tahrir get out, get out now 14 minutes ago via Twitter for BlackBerry®
8.May god take your souls if this childs parents are dead, may mubarak die. Mubaral your a murderer. Allah yel3ankoun, allah la ywafi2koun 21 minutes ago via Twitter for BlackBerry®
9.He doesn't know his patensts naems, he's 2 yrs max. Sarah has ggirl and rushdi calling ppl to come our way to omar makram 23 minutes ago via Twitter for BlackBerry®
10.Rushdi says fake I'm pro mubarak, and leave this way. Ppl families in Tahrir, the men will die there, please. Im heading throguh omar makram 26 minutes ago via Twitter for BlackBerry®
11.:'( omg I have someones child, I have a child. 2 yrs max, green eyes, says his name mahmoud. Tweet it for me 27 minutes ago via Twitter for BlackBerry®
12.PEOPLE LEAVE TAHRIR VIA OMAR MAKRAM, SEMIRAMIS THEN VIA NILE! #jan25 30 minutes ago via Twitter for BlackBerry®
13.Another entrance down... Omg there's dead people. There's dead people... 31 minutes ago via Twitter for BlackBerry®
14.@justimage how did u, tell us, please! 33 minutes ago via Twitter for BlackBerry®
15.HOW DO WE GET OUT, SOMEONE TELL US! 34 minutes ago via Twitter for BlackBerry®
16.We are trying to find way out, we are blocked from ll sides. Please, mubarak stop, mubarak stop them! 35 minutes ago via Twitter for BlackBerry®
17.Screaming, crying, injured, burned, they will kill us, I swear we will die. Omfg! #Jand25 36 minutes ago via Twitter for BlackBerry®
18.Pro mubarak protesters broke into square!!! Entrance broken! OMFG there's blood, omfg OmFGf 37 minutes ago via Twitter for BlackBerry®
19.Army blocking protesters near Nile bridge and in other areas, but can't stop the thugs?! #Jan25 38 minutes ago via Twitter for BlackBerry®
20.Yes I can confirm, tanks were abandoned. Tanks just left. I defended this army, I called them clean.... I was wrong #Jan25 40 minutes ago via Twitter for BlackBerry®
twitter user @SarahKaram1 wrote: 1. The motherfucker has ID! I can't see far, but it looks like we are surrounded?! about 1 hour ago via Mobile Web
2. SarahKaram1 Man clashing with @bloggerseif and Rushdi IS POLICE! HE HAS ID!! #jan25 about 1 hour ago via Mobile Web
3. Acid burns, they are acid burns! They are using acid!? about 1 hour ago via Mobile Web
4. OMG! @bloggerseif and man in serious fight. They are thugs! THUGS! about 1 hour ago via Mobile Web
5. Fainting ppl all over. I have never seen men cry like today #Jan25 about 1 hour ago via Mobile Web
6. SarahKaram1 Army took my phone's sim card, jokes on them. Came with 5 extras. about 2 hours ago via Mobile Web
7. Rushdi and @Bloggerseif are clashing with thugs, they keep getting attacked. Shant with them. about 3 hours ago via Mobile Web
8. Mubarak you are egyptian? Inta masri? Inta zift, about 3 hours ago via Mobile Web
9. Ppl referring to Lebanese men here as Lubnaniya el gad3an about 3 hours ago via Mobile Web
10. Lost sight of @bloggerseif, ppl pro mubarak are police, thugs, and low people! about 3 hours ago via Mobile Web
11. @gabrielghali I'm ok hayati, ali is in clashes about 3 hours ago via Mobile Web
12. More pro mubarak women pointing at me and woman named Samar. Praying going on, no rocks their way #Jan25 about 3 hours ago via Mobile Web
13. @abzzyy I'm fine, his phone with me. He and the men at front of clashes throwing rocks about 3 hours ago via Mobile Web
14. @bloggerseif in front of clashes, his phone with me. Rushdi and Seif are infront of thugs, small space between them #Jan25 about 3 hours ago via Mobile Web
15. Anyone else wnt to attack me!? I said I will die here, nd I m serious #Jan25 about 3 hours ago via Mobile Web
16. Thugs want our phones. Army if ppl die it is your fault! Mubarak you created a war and possibe bloodbath here #Jan25 about 4 hours ago via Mobile Web
17. @bloggerseif and rushdi are spread out, Shant is pushing people away from them about 4 hours ago via Mobile Web
18. @bloggerseif and Rushdi and lebanese armenian atacked by two pro mubarak men about 4 hours ago via Mobile Web
19. Rushdi and Shant standing next to @blogerseif. Seif challenging him #Jan25 about 4 hours ago via Mobile Web
20. Pro Mubarak asking @bloggerseif what he is doing here. Clashes can't be ignored. #Jan25 about 4 hours ago via Mobile Web
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 16 guests