Elvis » Thu Oct 07, 2021 11:57 pm wrote:Belligerent Savant wrote:they're at 15% vaccination. U.S. is over 50%. What measures are you referring to? Can you spell them out?
Most recently I summarized Taiwan 's actions back on page 241:Looking again at Taiwan, where new Covid cases are one per day. That's out of 23 million people.
What did Taiwan do that's different?
The Taiwan government:
- immediately took command of the necessary resources
- immediately banned export of PPE
- guaranteed to manufacturers the purchase of all PPE they could make
- tested people daily
- conducted unintrusive contact tracing
- imposed limited isolation
- provided quarantine facilities for infected persons
- encouraged use of facemasks, provided free.
The US did pretty much the opposite, sitting on its hands, letting the "free market" make book. In Taiwan they're playing baseball in crowded stadiums again.
The "unintrusive" tracing part is from an article I read that said Taiwanese are jealous of their privacy, and the government, being sensitive to that, used some method that didn't use their phones. Sorry, I didn't save the URLs, but I think the general reportage goes along those lines.
Notice vaccines aren't on the list; it seems they weren't really necessary with ordinary prevention measures—granted, at extraordinary levels, but I think they just had a good plan together. Who knows?—maybe the April spike was caused by the vaccine? I don't know.
But masks are not a viable defense. They never were.
Note all the charts in the prior page by me and Stickdog. Many cities/countries/islands with high mask compliance continue to observe spikes.
Contact tracing has not shown itself to be consistently effective either.
All prior guidance for influenza-like viruses made clear that NPIs (non-pharmaceutical interventions) were not broadly effective for any extended duration.
Of course, keeping those ill and compromised isolated and/or quarantined -- to help keep spread among the healthy -- certainly can help minimize harm to the vulnerable.
Early treatment options in particular absolutely can help.
In lieu of vaccination, how is Taiwan treating the ill?