Strauss-Kahn New York Case May Curb Libertine Ways of Powerful French Men
By Helene Fouquet -
Strauss-Kahn Lawyer Says Hotel Sex-Assault Charges Untrue
Dominique Strauss-Kahn, former managing director of the International Monetary Fund, right, with attorney Benjamin Brafman during his arraignment in Manhattan criminal court in New York. Photographer: Andrew Gombert/Pool via Bloomberg
The sexual escapades of powerful men in France have always been met with Gallic shrugs. Not anymore.
The arrest in New York of former International Monetary Fund chief Dominique Strauss-Kahn on charges of attempted rape is forcing men to watch what they say and emboldening women to challenge the modern-day version of France’s “droit de cuissage,” a feudal practice giving masters the right to have sex with female servants. It’s prompting introspection in the media over whether its laissez-faire attitude toward private lives of those in power helps them act with impunity.
“Since power is often thought of as an aphrodisiac, there was a sort of acceptance of men’s excesses toward women,” said Rachel Mulot, a member of a feminist group called “La Barbe,” or The Beard, which on May 22 joined protests in Paris against the “dominant male.” The Strauss-Kahn case may serve as a trigger to help victims of sexual assaults to break the “taboo of rape” in France, she said.
Strauss-Kahn, 62, was indicted May 19 on charges of criminal sex, attempted rape, sexual abuse, unlawful imprisonment and forcible touching of a 32-year-old maid at the Sofitel hotel in Manhattan. The former French finance minister, who had been a leading contender for next year’s presidential elections, denies the allegations and will plead not guilty, his lawyers say. DSK, as he’s known in France, is under house arrest in Manhattan.
After DSK
Early reactions from male French commentators to the maid’s allegations sparked outrage. Jean-Francois Kahn, founder of weekly magazine Marianne and a witness at Strauss-Kahn’s third marriage in 1991, laughed as he said on state-owned radio station France Culture, that “there may have been a careless action, how should I put it… the shagging of a servant.” He later apologized.
For France, “there will be a before and an after DSK,” former Prime Minister Jean-Pierre Raffarin was quoted as saying in Le Figaro newspaper over the weekend. “We are not saints, but our actions need to be coherent with our thinking. Those in power need to be exemplary.”
While sexual assault and attempted rape allegations that Strauss-Kahn is accused of in New York are also crimes in his home country, the French have been more indulgent when it comes to the indiscretions of their politicians.
“Earlier, kings had their droit de cuissage with servants in palaces; this looked like a powerful person trying it on a maid in a New York hotel,” Jean Quatremer, a journalist with newspaper Liberation, said in an interview.
‘Sexus Politicus’
Unlike in the U.S., where sexual scandals have forced the resignation of four members of the House of Representatives in the past five years and ruined the careers of a former vice- presidential nominee and presidential candidate, sex is treated as private matter in France. No French politician in recent years has been brought down by a sex scandal.
In a 2006 book called “Sexus Politicus,” co-authors Christophe Deloire and Christophe Dubois show how sex and politics are inextricable in France, even though there is little in the press to prove it.
Former President Felix Faure died in 1899 in the arms of his mistress, the wife of painter Adolphe Steinheil. President Jacques Chirac’s nocturnal adventures were widely known, the authors said. “Do you know where my husband is tonight?” his wife is supposed to have asked the chauffeur, the book said. During Francois Mitterrand’s reign, it was an open secret that he had fathered a daughter with his mistress.
Just last year, Culture Minister Frederic Mitterrand, who admitted to having paid for sex with boys during trips to Asia, kept his job after saying the boys were of legal age.
Laissez-Faire
The laissez-faire attitude gives powerful people in France a sense of impunity, said Claude Katz an attorney, specializing in sexual harassment cases.
The Strauss-Kahn affair “can move the lines slowly but surely,” Katz said. “It will empower victims of sexual abuse in France because if a maid can speak against a powerful man, others will have a stronger voice.”
Laws reinforcing women’s rights and safety are relatively recent in France. The law making rape a crime dates back only to 1980. Earlier decrees were based on 19th century moral codes. A law on sexual-harassment was approved in 1992 and one on moral harassment was passed in 2002.
The last bill to fight violence against women was passed last year. Government studies show there are 75,000 rapes a year in the country. Only about 10 percent of the victims filed complaints, women’s groups say.
Soul Searching
The sufferer is “often seen as a bit guilty,” said Chantal Brunel, a lawmaker from President Nicolas Sarkozy’s Union for a Popular Movement party who submitted the 2010 bill on violence. “Some people said the maid ‘wanted it,’ which was stunning and revolting. The reality of a possible rape has broken the code of silence. ”
Brunel said the mood has begun to change among lawmakers at the National Assembly, the lower chamber of Parliament.
“The men’s views and jokes have changed,” she said. “You can sense that they are and will be much more careful from now on and we won’t hear as many sexist remarks.”
The press is doing some soul searching of its own.
“In this country of sleazy men, will we finally dare to say that macho behavior breeds impunity?” Christine Lambert, a reporter for Marianne, wrote in the May 21 issue.
Liberation’s Quatremer called Strauss-Kahn’s relations with women a “problem” in a 2007 article, before he took the IMF job, saying “he often skates close to harassment.”
‘Cultural Leap’
Debates on the media since the DSK case have focused on whether journalists owe their readers more than what they are often ready to divulge on politician’s private lives.
The effects of Strauss-Kahn’s case also may be felt in other walks of French life, said Catherine Mabileau, who heads international human resources for Roseland, New-Jersey based ADP Inc., a payroll-services company.
“We’re not like in the U.S. where work relations are extremely respectful, codified in ways that sometimes kill spontaneity,” she said. “But we are changing what is acceptable and what can no longer be accepted. There is a cultural leap here to be made.”
http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2011-05-2 ... h-men.html
*