Ex-FBI Translator Sibel Edmonds Tests Justice Dept. Again
Posted: Tue Aug 04, 2009 10:15 pmEx-FBI Translator Tests Justice Dept. Again
By Jeff Stein | August 4, 2009
Sibel Edmonds may never get her day in court - or at least the kind she wants.
The former FBI translator has spent seven years trying to get a court to hear her allegations that foreign agents, in particular Turkish intelligence, had penetrated her unit, the State Department, the Pentagon and Congress.
This weekend she's going to try again.
Edmonds, a multilingual Iranian raised partly in Turkey who graduated from college in the U.S., was fired by the FBI in 2002 after lodging complaints of incompetence and corruption in the translation unit.
Although the Justice Department's Office of the Inspector General would eventually validate her complaints, in 2002 Attorney General John D. Ashcroft threw a cloak of secrecy over the entire affair via the so-called state secrets privilege, effectively smothering Edmonds's whistleblower suit against the FBI.
In 2004, the government won another gag order against her when U.S. District Court judge Reggie B. Walton ruled that Edmonds could not answer questions about her FBI allegations in a suit by families of 9/11 victims against the Saudi government.
This week, Edmonds was scheduled to give a deposition regarding Turkish intelligence activities in an arcane congressional election dispute in Ohio.
Rep. Jean Schmidt, R-Ohio, had filed a complaint with the Ohio Board of Elections contending that a rival candidate in 2008 had slandered her with a charge that she took campaign cash from Turkish interests - "blood money," he called it - to vote against a congressional resolution blaming Ankara for the "genocide" of 1.5 million Armenians during the First World War.
The candidate, David Krikorian, who ran against Schmidt as an Independent but wants to challenge her again in 2010 as a Democrat, planned to take a deposition from Edmonds on Saturday, Aug. 8.
On Monday, Edmonds notified the Justice Department of what she planned to tell Krikorian:
"How certain Turkish entities had illegally infiltrated and influenced various U.S. government agencies and officials, including but not limited to the Department of State, the Department of Defense and individual members of the United States Congress."
She and her attorneys gave the government "until the end of the day to respond," she said, "however, we received no response."
They gave the Justice Department another deadline -- until noon today, to respond.
No answer.
Edmonds says that without a red light, she plans to go ahead now and spill the beans.
"Yes, I will provide a deposition unless DOJ officially bars me from doing so," she said by e-mail Tuesday evening.
She invited "the public/media" to attend.
A senior Justice Department official dismissed Edmonds's maneuver as theatrics.
Edmonds's nondisclosure agreement (NDA) with the FBI requires her to give the bureau 30 days advance notice of her desire to speak about issues related to her employment, the official said.
"State Secrets is not on the table here," said the official, demanding anonymity in exchange for discussing the issue. "This just about her NDA, period."
The official declined to predict how the Attorney General will respond to Edmonds's demand for an immediate answer - if at all -- or what action the Justice Department might take if she violates the agreement.
Edmonds said she has no control over when a party wants to depose her.
Whistleblower Asked to Testify in Ohio Genocide Denial Case
By Asbarez Staff on Aug 4th, 2009 and filed under Armenia,
WASHINGTON—Attorneys for FBI whistleblower Sibel D. Edmonds have requested that Attorney General Holder review the state secrets privilege invoked in her case and reverse the decision made under former President Bush. This will free her to testify on behalf of Democratic Congressional candidate David Krikorian, in connection with a complaint initiated by Genocide denier Rep. Jean Schmidt before the Ohio Elections Commission
Edmonds was illegally fired from the FBI due to her protected disclosures. An independent investigation by the Department of Justice Office of Inspector General confirmed the serious misconduct committed by the FBI and the illegality of her termination. On or about October 18, 2002 the previous administration invoked the state secrets privilege in order to have Ms. Edmonds’s whistleblower/First Amendment claims dismissed and to protect the government from embarrassment.
Edmonds has now been requested to provide sworn deposition and affidavit testimony in a case pending before the Ohio Elections Commission in the Schmidt v. Krikorian case. This case raises nationally significant issues of electoral fraud and violation of law. The state secrets privilege has stifled Ms. Edmonds for the past seven years, and this deposition will be the first time that she will put her knowledge on the record.
Schmidt has brought charges against her likely Democratic opponent in the 2010 election for what she claims are false statements made by Krikorian in connection with Schmidt’s vocal opposition to Congressional measures to commemorate the Armenian Genocide. During the last election cycle, Schmidt received more than $30,000 in contributions from individuals and political action committees advancing the Turkish government’s position to deny the fact of the Armenian Genocide and oppose Congressional measures to commemorate what is widely acknowledged as the first Genocide of the twentieth century. The trial on Schmidt’s charges is scheduled for August 13 before the Ohio Elections Commission.
Since her election to Congress, Jean Schmidt has become an active and vocal apologist for the Turkish government’s position on the Armenian Genocide and has solicited and received tens of thousands of dollars in campaign contributions from Turkish Americans and affiliated political action committees. David Krikorian has been working to expose the connection between Schmidt’s actions as a Member of Congress and her political contributions.
“Jean Schmidt’s active participation in the Turkish Government’s campaign to deny and cover up this internationally recognized crime against humanity is well documented and readily traceable” said said Mark Geragos who will serve as the lead attorney on the case.
“Schmidt’s mertiless complaint against David is yet another attempt by the Turkish Government and its apologists to intimidate those with the audacity to speak the truth about this ongoing human right violation. David Krikorian understands that the Turkish Government’s attempt to suppress the truth about the most heinous crime known to humankind transcends the interests of Armenian Americans and is a cause for concern to all those of good conscience. David is a man of principle and despite Schmidt’s specious allegations, remains undeterred in his resolve to bring this important human rights issue to light,” added Geragos.
Given the pendency of this case and the request for her testimony, the National Whistleblowers Legal Defense and Education Fund requested that the Attorney General immediately and independently review the basis upon which that privilege was initially invoked, and formally and in writing withdraw that privilege. At the time of this release, two separate deadlines for the Department of Justice to respond to the attorney’s letter had passed, and consequently the deposition has been scheduled for Saturday. Although a request was hand delivered to the Department of Justice, the Attorney General’s office informed counsel that they were having difficulty locating it.
According to Stephen M. Kohn, the Executive Director of the National Whistleblowers Center and one of Ms. Edmonds’s attorneys, “The Obama administration must take a fresh look at how the state secrets privilege was improperly used to hide government misconduct from the public view. The Edmonds case was the first case the ‘privilege’ was invoked, and it must be the first case the ‘privilege’ is revoked. The government’s misguided attempt to cover up wrongdoing by abusing the state secrets privilege to bully a whistleblower must end. Ms. Edmonds has been requested to provide testimony in court. She will do so unless the government again invokes the privilege to quash her First Amendment rights.”
Edmonds’s deposition is scheduled for Saturday, August 8, at 10:30am. It will be held at the National Whistleblowers Center at 3238 P. St. NW, Washington, DC. The event is open to the press.
By Jeff Stein | August 4, 2009
Sibel Edmonds may never get her day in court - or at least the kind she wants.
The former FBI translator has spent seven years trying to get a court to hear her allegations that foreign agents, in particular Turkish intelligence, had penetrated her unit, the State Department, the Pentagon and Congress.
This weekend she's going to try again.
Edmonds, a multilingual Iranian raised partly in Turkey who graduated from college in the U.S., was fired by the FBI in 2002 after lodging complaints of incompetence and corruption in the translation unit.
Although the Justice Department's Office of the Inspector General would eventually validate her complaints, in 2002 Attorney General John D. Ashcroft threw a cloak of secrecy over the entire affair via the so-called state secrets privilege, effectively smothering Edmonds's whistleblower suit against the FBI.
In 2004, the government won another gag order against her when U.S. District Court judge Reggie B. Walton ruled that Edmonds could not answer questions about her FBI allegations in a suit by families of 9/11 victims against the Saudi government.
This week, Edmonds was scheduled to give a deposition regarding Turkish intelligence activities in an arcane congressional election dispute in Ohio.
Rep. Jean Schmidt, R-Ohio, had filed a complaint with the Ohio Board of Elections contending that a rival candidate in 2008 had slandered her with a charge that she took campaign cash from Turkish interests - "blood money," he called it - to vote against a congressional resolution blaming Ankara for the "genocide" of 1.5 million Armenians during the First World War.
The candidate, David Krikorian, who ran against Schmidt as an Independent but wants to challenge her again in 2010 as a Democrat, planned to take a deposition from Edmonds on Saturday, Aug. 8.
On Monday, Edmonds notified the Justice Department of what she planned to tell Krikorian:
"How certain Turkish entities had illegally infiltrated and influenced various U.S. government agencies and officials, including but not limited to the Department of State, the Department of Defense and individual members of the United States Congress."
She and her attorneys gave the government "until the end of the day to respond," she said, "however, we received no response."
They gave the Justice Department another deadline -- until noon today, to respond.
No answer.
Edmonds says that without a red light, she plans to go ahead now and spill the beans.
"Yes, I will provide a deposition unless DOJ officially bars me from doing so," she said by e-mail Tuesday evening.
She invited "the public/media" to attend.
A senior Justice Department official dismissed Edmonds's maneuver as theatrics.
Edmonds's nondisclosure agreement (NDA) with the FBI requires her to give the bureau 30 days advance notice of her desire to speak about issues related to her employment, the official said.
"State Secrets is not on the table here," said the official, demanding anonymity in exchange for discussing the issue. "This just about her NDA, period."
The official declined to predict how the Attorney General will respond to Edmonds's demand for an immediate answer - if at all -- or what action the Justice Department might take if she violates the agreement.
Edmonds said she has no control over when a party wants to depose her.
Whistleblower Asked to Testify in Ohio Genocide Denial Case
By Asbarez Staff on Aug 4th, 2009 and filed under Armenia,
WASHINGTON—Attorneys for FBI whistleblower Sibel D. Edmonds have requested that Attorney General Holder review the state secrets privilege invoked in her case and reverse the decision made under former President Bush. This will free her to testify on behalf of Democratic Congressional candidate David Krikorian, in connection with a complaint initiated by Genocide denier Rep. Jean Schmidt before the Ohio Elections Commission
Edmonds was illegally fired from the FBI due to her protected disclosures. An independent investigation by the Department of Justice Office of Inspector General confirmed the serious misconduct committed by the FBI and the illegality of her termination. On or about October 18, 2002 the previous administration invoked the state secrets privilege in order to have Ms. Edmonds’s whistleblower/First Amendment claims dismissed and to protect the government from embarrassment.
Edmonds has now been requested to provide sworn deposition and affidavit testimony in a case pending before the Ohio Elections Commission in the Schmidt v. Krikorian case. This case raises nationally significant issues of electoral fraud and violation of law. The state secrets privilege has stifled Ms. Edmonds for the past seven years, and this deposition will be the first time that she will put her knowledge on the record.
Schmidt has brought charges against her likely Democratic opponent in the 2010 election for what she claims are false statements made by Krikorian in connection with Schmidt’s vocal opposition to Congressional measures to commemorate the Armenian Genocide. During the last election cycle, Schmidt received more than $30,000 in contributions from individuals and political action committees advancing the Turkish government’s position to deny the fact of the Armenian Genocide and oppose Congressional measures to commemorate what is widely acknowledged as the first Genocide of the twentieth century. The trial on Schmidt’s charges is scheduled for August 13 before the Ohio Elections Commission.
Since her election to Congress, Jean Schmidt has become an active and vocal apologist for the Turkish government’s position on the Armenian Genocide and has solicited and received tens of thousands of dollars in campaign contributions from Turkish Americans and affiliated political action committees. David Krikorian has been working to expose the connection between Schmidt’s actions as a Member of Congress and her political contributions.
“Jean Schmidt’s active participation in the Turkish Government’s campaign to deny and cover up this internationally recognized crime against humanity is well documented and readily traceable” said said Mark Geragos who will serve as the lead attorney on the case.
“Schmidt’s mertiless complaint against David is yet another attempt by the Turkish Government and its apologists to intimidate those with the audacity to speak the truth about this ongoing human right violation. David Krikorian understands that the Turkish Government’s attempt to suppress the truth about the most heinous crime known to humankind transcends the interests of Armenian Americans and is a cause for concern to all those of good conscience. David is a man of principle and despite Schmidt’s specious allegations, remains undeterred in his resolve to bring this important human rights issue to light,” added Geragos.
Given the pendency of this case and the request for her testimony, the National Whistleblowers Legal Defense and Education Fund requested that the Attorney General immediately and independently review the basis upon which that privilege was initially invoked, and formally and in writing withdraw that privilege. At the time of this release, two separate deadlines for the Department of Justice to respond to the attorney’s letter had passed, and consequently the deposition has been scheduled for Saturday. Although a request was hand delivered to the Department of Justice, the Attorney General’s office informed counsel that they were having difficulty locating it.
According to Stephen M. Kohn, the Executive Director of the National Whistleblowers Center and one of Ms. Edmonds’s attorneys, “The Obama administration must take a fresh look at how the state secrets privilege was improperly used to hide government misconduct from the public view. The Edmonds case was the first case the ‘privilege’ was invoked, and it must be the first case the ‘privilege’ is revoked. The government’s misguided attempt to cover up wrongdoing by abusing the state secrets privilege to bully a whistleblower must end. Ms. Edmonds has been requested to provide testimony in court. She will do so unless the government again invokes the privilege to quash her First Amendment rights.”
Edmonds’s deposition is scheduled for Saturday, August 8, at 10:30am. It will be held at the National Whistleblowers Center at 3238 P. St. NW, Washington, DC. The event is open to the press.
)
