jfshade wrote:I think most people would choose Door #1 ("Andrew is Shutter Island inmate #67.")
Door #1, yes. And yes to your parenthetical, except that it's not incompatible with Door #2, i.e. "This is the mess they made of Teddy after two years as Shutter Island inmate #67." (And now they're not sending him to a lobotomy but to massacre three men in a bar?)
But both readings break down fatally for me. The straight reading fails, among other reasons, because it suggests that the staff - not to mention a bunch of criminally insane inmates - choreographed the charade that perfectly, and that the good doctors managed to script in a hurricane - arriving at the proper time and inflicting just the right amount of damage.
Yes yes.
As for the alt reading, consider this bit of dialog when Teddy bursts in on Dr. Cawley in the lighthouse (paraphrased):
Dr. Cawley: "Why are you all wet, baby?"
Teddy: "What did you say?"
D.C.: "You heard what I said."
Teddy asked Dolores the exact same question when he got home and found her soaking wet, after she drowned the children. How would Dr. Cawley have known about that unless Andrew had told him?
Because he was reinforcing the false memory they've been causing Teddy to construct under drugs and hypnosis for the last two years?
Our protagonist can neither be Teddy nor Andrew; I rather like it that way. And I agree wholeheartedly with the comments about the cinematography and Robbie Robertson's brilliant soundtrack, which is worth getting to hear the full pieces, not just the snippets used in the film.
So have I also decided.
The Consul wrote: Shutter to me felt like an MK kind of work in and of itself, it toyed and teased us becoming a kind of prince of neucleotides of the mind but almost seemed, at the end, to say....okay okay we're just a movie, you knew we couldn't go there, all the way, right?...and pushes you back out into the sunshine and rain with a circus barker's poignant remindance, however obviously hollow, "back to the real world, back to life, back to sanity!"
Yup. Exploitation movie for paranoid intellectuals who may have dabbled in hallucinogenics.
Those tarot cards, true. This time I was very pleased with how it started completely white and then the ship emerged from the fog.
At that point I had to scream at myself just shut up and watch the damned movie! I was okay until Leo/Teddy got in the jeep with Ted Levine.
I liked that scene this time. Andrew or Teddy, I think the dialogue wasn't hallucinated either way.
Except insofar as a movie is always a hallucination, etc.
it does not matter what you think you know or what you believe you think.
I have to disagree. It doesn't matter what "Shutter Island" thinks it knows or believes I think. I get to do that.