MinM » Mon Nov 22, 2010 6:11 pm wrote:
As most readers of the CTKA site know, and most serious people on this case realize, Hartmann and Waldron spent nearly two thousand pages discussing declassified documents that they either misread or misrepresented. Their two books are based upon contingency plans, which President Kennedy never took seriously, about an invasion of Cuba. And these plans are clearly marked as such. Further, in their first book, Ultimate Sacrifice, their alleged coup plotter, the man who would lead the revolt against Fidel Castro, was clearly implied as being Che Guevara. Which was ridiculous on its face. Eventually, they switched to Juan Almeida. But they were humiliated once again when Malcolm Blunt and Ed Sherry discovered NSA intercepts revealing that Almeida was on his way to Africa at the time of the coup! This literally took the heart out of their fantastic C-Day plot. As did the fact that it was later revealed that no one in any high position in the military or intelligence community knew of the coming invasion—which was to be by flotillas of Cuban exiles supplemented by both the CIA and the Pentagon. National Security Adviser McGeorge Bundy did not know. Secretary of Defense Robert McNamara did not know. And CIA Director of Plans Richard Helms did not know.
So here you had a US sponsored coup in Cuba which no one in the American military–intelligence community knew of, and apparently neither did the designated coup leader, who was flying across the Atlantic on his way to a different continent at the time.
I always wondered how Hartmann and Waldron came up with this concept of the top Cuban leaders (Guevara, then Almeida) secretly working against Castro. But on page 296 of
The Man Who Knew Too Much by Dick Russell, this paragraph stood out as a possible explanation:
"Under Scott, the Mexico branch of the CIA was not afraid to play hard ball. A recently declassified document reveals that, in 1963, to foment dissension, Scott's agents planted phony documents on a Cuban government official that indicated Castro's vice minister of defense was in fact a CIA operative. When Cuban security discovered those documents, four completely innocent people were convicted of treason and thrown into a Cuban jail for years."
So Hartmann's just playing the same game Winston Scott did 50 years ago.