On Mar 08, 2008,
Hugh Manatee Wins said:
The Beatles 1966 trip to the Phillipines (sic) seems to have included government sabotage of their appearance and media manipulation which led to violence there and at their next stop in India. They retired from public performing that year.
HMW is suggesting that sinister forces were behind the Beatles Manila fiasco. Although HMW does not come out and say it, I interpreted his assertion - and please correct me if I'm wrong - as some type of government-sponsored psychological warfare/propaganda effort to discredit the Beatles as, ostensibly, a disruptive social phenomenon.
Well, I've just finished reading
The Beatles: The Biography by Bob Spitz, and I'm inclined to view the Beatles' problems in the Philippines as stemming from their turning down Imelda Marcos's invitation to a morning reception. See excerpt from book
here.
Although Spitz's book does not explain definitively what happened, it appears that Brian Epstein had made the decision to turn down the invitation when it was received while the Beatles were in Japan, their previous stop. At any rate, either the "Regrets" reply did not reach the Marcos staff on time or Marcos ignored their answer and planned the palace function as if it had been accepted. There was no way, apparently, that Brian Epstein would have reversed his decision since the Beatles had had their fill of such receptions where everybody and their uncle would bring their kids along for the inevitable screamfest. After their evening show - their second concert of the day in Manila - the Beatles discovered that their escort out of the stadium had disappeared. They made a very difficult and harrowing escape from the Philippines because every Philippino seemed to have taken it personally that the Beatles had snubbed their President. So, to me, the Manila fiasco was the result of a bad public-relations decision made by Brian Epstein (perhaps he was convinced that the Beatles would have turned it down anyway).
As for India and the violence there, I wouldn't know. It is at their stop in India that the Beatles decided not to tour anymore (p. 625 of Spitz's book).