Honestly, voting on its own does nothing. All governments are always compromised. But not voting on its own is as pointless as voting. Government onl;y works when citizens hassle the fuck out of it to do what they want.
Why has corporate whoreville done so well out of Oama?
Cos they were the only ones hassling him about how to do his job (cos thats what lobby groups do.) There was a huge opportunity post Nov 08 to get citizens engaged in US politics, only the "right" has taken advantage of this tho, and people wonder why the corporates did so well out of Obama.
If you think its about voting then shutting up and letting your betters make their decisions, which is whats happened with "the left" or the non corporate interests since the election (and thats the sort of message the likes of John Stewart have pushed non stop,) then of course your democracy won't work.
And really there isn't much difference between what you all are saying.
Simulist wrote:Cosmic Cowbell wrote:Simulist wrote:Oh, there are differences: the Republican Party does evil shit, and the Democratic Party (sometimes) protests.
Except when it helps them. Or does more evil shit all on its own.
(Which is a lot.)
So what should we do?
We should stop pretending.
We should stop pretending that any president who covers up for the torturers of children is someone worthy of our support. We should stop pretending that any political party which continues to support unnecessary wars resulting in millions of dead and ruined lives is worthy of our support.
Stop pretending. Until that first step is taken, the next steps of radical non-violent non-cooperation with this evil system will not be taken and, in fact, will not even be recognized as necessary.
Ok what you all should have done was raised hell he moment that first drone attack (on the 20th Jan 2009 iirc) took place, and not shut up since.
The president works for you lot, believe it or not, and this argument is effectively ignoring that.
Doesn't matter how much you dislike Obama, if you are a US citizen you are responsible for him. That includes you Stim. I think people should stop pretending that they aren't responsible for Obama, for Bush, and for everything done in their name. (I'm not talking about govt conspiracies here either, I'm talking about the open stuff done in your name like bombing families in Pakistan with drones.) I understand you are appalled and feel powerless to stop what you object to, and want it stopped yesterday or 9 years ago.
But unless you act it won't, and like it or not thats all there is to it.
The only blame "the American people" can apportion re the failures of Obama is on themselves. If they'd held the "hope and change" bullshit up as a real agreement, and held him to it then things would be different now.
You can cry about how hard it is, or whats stacked against you but thats actually bullshit.
If it means enough you'll find a way (whoever s in government.) or you won't.
In which case you failed.
In which case you learn and go again.
Its all well and good to yell "Fuck Obama" to the wind. That won't actually achieve anything.
If you yelled "Fuck YOU Obama!!! You said this and this and now you are going back on it and we want it." - in the right way, effectively then things would be different. Obviously this didn't happen.
I don't agree with CCs opinions about what happens if the US pulls out of Afpak. I think you are wrong on that CC. Tho I accept I could be wrong. I have spent days arguing with my brother about that recently, I actaully never thought he'd disagree with me about this ... but ... I still disagree with him, but I can understand how he comes to his POV, and maybe its not as wrong as I thought.
(Either way the current policy and execution of policy is fucked at best imo.)
But I do agree with his question and I don't think you answered it Stimulist.
No one is pretending we support those things. Those things are done by power, power is sposed to be answerable to its population.
Make it answerable.
(When you work out how let me know.)