hiddenite » Wed May 29, 2013 9:09 am wrote:Joe Hillshoist » 29 May 2013 09:43 wrote:Its a big deal if there's one standard for some people and another for others, especially if the decision is based on how someone felt after a 2.5 hour commute home from work.
totally agree with this that Joe wrote too . The decision was arbitrary and unfairly applied , if personal attacks are not allowed then both posters in that particular fray were guilty .
There have been reams of threads where the matter of the OP has been abandoned in favour of sarcastic videos or one line detractions and these have gone on and on with no mod response.
It makes any real discussion in here pointless . There seems to be a greater appetite for personal attacks than there is for issue based debate.
Either the rules apply to everyone equally or they are not applied at all.
Not all personal attacks are equal.
For example, Simulist's quote below is a criticism of the application of logic to an argument, which is pretty much one of the main purposes of this board. Especially when the argument posits the position that (gore warning)
these people are either photoshopped, lying, and/or "just greedy mother fuckers who are keeping quiet for the money."
Simulist wrote:If you haven't figured even that out yet, it's no wonder you come up with all the crackpot stuff you promote here so readily.
Simulist could have been more tactful about it, and he was warned, publicly and privately, but I determined that it didn't rise to the level of a suspendable personal attack, because again, he was criticizing the logic of C_w's arguments, as opposed to just name-calling.
And incidentally, We (the mods) have allowed the promotion of those theories for page after page, over multiple threads, for the past six weeks or so. Until now, C_w has been able to say whatever she wanted to say about "crisis actors," photoshopped disaster scenes, and greedy, mother fucking, impromptu amputee victims.
C_w's below quote, on the other hand, is just name-calling. Period. It has no purpose, other than to denigrate and incite, and as I said, after I took a bit of time to reflect, when I wasn't in a panic to catch my bus, I determined that it rose to the level of a suspendable offense, especially when coupled with other recent warnings C_w has received from myself as well as the other mods behind the scenes.
Canadian_watcher wrote:and if you haven't figured out that there's plenty of this world that is not hostile it's no wonder you come off as such an angry, classless, big mouth asshole on a continuous basis.
Now let's get this thread back on topic.